Baby Shoe Fittings

Baby Shoe Fittings at Carella’s Shoes

Start their first steps off right.

At Carella’s Shoes, fitting baby shoes is more than a service - it's something we've specialized in for decades. We’ve helped generations of families in New Jersey (and now across the country) find the perfect first shoes for their little ones.

We know those tiny feet grow fast, and we’re here to make sure they get the support they need from the start.

When Does a Baby Need Shoes?

A common question we hear: When should I get shoes for my baby?

The answer: As soon as your baby becomes weight-bearing.
That means:

  • Pulling up to stand
  • Cruising along furniture
  • Using walker toys or activity centers
  • Starting to take assisted steps

Even before full walking, once they’re putting pressure on their feet, it’s time to make sure they have soft, supportive shoes to protect their feet and promote healthy development.

Why Proper Fit Matters

Baby feet are still forming - the bones are soft, and the shape is changing fast. Ill-fitting shoes can:

  • Restrict natural growth
  • Lead to foot or alignment issues
  • Cause discomfort or delay walking confidence

We take detailed measurements (length and width), check toe room, heel grip, and observe how your baby stands and moves. It’s a gentle, stress-free process, and we’re experts at working with wiggly little ones!

Baby Feet Grow Fast

On average, babies go up a size every 3 months until they are about 3 years of age, then it will vary. 
That’s why we created our Baby Shoe Reminder Program - a free service that sends you occasional email reminders to check their size and stop in for a fitting.

No pressure - just a friendly nudge so you’re never caught off guard by a growth spurt.

Brands We Trust

We carry baby and toddler shoes designed specifically for new walkers, including:

  • Stride Rite
  • Tsukihoshi
  • New Balance
  • Froddo
  • Naturino
  • Primigi
  • Falcatto
  • Skechers

  • Plus wide width and orthotic-friendly options

Each pair is chosen for quality, flexibility, and the right balance of structure and softness.

Walk-Ins Welcome

No appointment needed - all of our staff are trained to properly fit baby shoes.
But if you prefer, you're always welcome to call or message us ahead of time. We're happy to answer questions or set aside time for a more personalized visit.

Our Baby Shoe Reminder Program

When you buy your baby’s shoes at Carella’s, you’re automatically enrolled in our reminder program (as long as you share your email with us).

Here’s how it works:

  • Personalized reminders: We’ll email you 2–3 months after your purchase to check if it’s time for the next size.

  • Helpful tips: Learn about healthy foot development and proper shoe fit.

  • Early access: Be the first to hear about new styles, special events, and seasonal promotions.

It’s our way of making sure your little one always has the right fit, without you having to remember the timing yourself.

Why Parents Choose Carella’s Shoes

  • Family-owned and trusted since 1946
  • Generations of experience fitting babies and first-time walkers
  • Gentle, knowledgeable staff who know how to keep fittings smooth and as stress-free as possible
  • A wide selection of developmentally appropriate footwear